In the Orbit of UFO Enthusiasts
Operating in a Galaxy of
Doubt, Disbelief and Dismissal,
UFO Buffs Make Their Case That . . . We Are Not
Alone
By Joe
Heim
Sunday, October 21, 2007; Page N01
As a meeting spot for UFO enthusiasts,
"When I first started 20 years ago, it was a bunch of old guys with their pocket protectors, but now the meetings are getting more diverse," organizer Sue Swiatek says.
Swiatek, a software analyst by day, is the state
director of the
On Saturday, they will be among the featured
speakers at Mysteries of Space and Sky IV: Sixty Years of UFOs, a daylong
conference open to the public at
For UFO buffs, 2007 is a multiple anniversary
year. It was 60 years ago that whatever happened in
Five years ago, a new case arose when F-16 fighter jets were scrambled from Andrews Air Force Base to pursue what turned out to be -- dum-de-dum-dum -- an unknown craft. Spooky, huh? And because it happened exactly 50 years to the day of saucers being reported over the region, the event prompted a flurry of local ufological activity. (And, no, don't insert a "we all know how painful that can be" joke here).
Of course, UFO enthusiasts are used to having their ideas about aliens and intergalactic spacecraft ridiculed. Those who opine that there are "others" out there are bound to hear they're more than a little out there themselves. If you talk to enough of them, you realize they have heard all of the insults before: nut job, wacko, loony, space case. But perhaps the most insulting thing to call a UFO believer is, well, a believer.
To believe, they argue, is to imply that there is
room for doubt. But, they tell you, if you study the cases, follow the facts,
examine the evidence, there is no room for doubt. "We're not believers; we're
concluders," says Paul Nahay of
Paul Nahay, 49,
Job: Computer consultant
When did you first get interested in UFOs?
I recall being in fifth grade and getting a book
on UFOs called something like "Is Anybody Out There?" I had the usual
teenage-boy interest in the subject. Living in
Ever had a UFO experience?
Mine was
Nov. 10, 2002. It was a rectangular, impossibly large, dark object, with a
strange texture, miles away in the sky. There was not a cloud in the sky; it was
about 1:30 in afternoon on Route 295 in
What
is it that most convinces you that UFOs exist?
I'm not
interested in the unidentified objects. I'm interested in ones that are clearly
identifiable and piloted by things that are not human and are clearly
intelligent. The volume and quality of the evidence is what's convincing.
Why do
you think UFOs are visiting Earth?
"Why is
this happening?" is a very loaded and dangerous question. Any answer is in
danger of being shot down. . . . Many people, including my wife, view the
abduction phenomenon as complete fiction and as a psychological aberration. . .
. The implication, and this is dangerous to extrapolate and somewhat fringe
theory, is that they are in the process of integrating with us. I know it sounds
crazy and like the movies, but that seems to be the case.
How do
you deal with skeptics?
I
personally try not to because they [tick] me off so much. It doesn't have to be
a matter of belief; there are studies that can be read. There's no end of
reputable books. Most skeptics either know nothing about the field or they
simply echo back the bogus reports that have been made.
Has
your involvement with the subject of UFOs hampered your relationships or career
plans?
I am
reluctant to talk about it. It's the one subject that you can't talk about in
polite company. [Laughs.] I've been lucky because I've been a freelancer. I know
people who have full-time jobs, particularly with government or military, and
they have to be more careful. It has caused some rough edges in some personal
areas. [Laughs.]
What
would it take to make acceptance of UFO phenomena more widespread?
There are
highly credible witnesses, people who we entrust, and when they say, "I saw this
thing" . . . you can't just whisk this away. I mean, even Jimmy Carter saw one.
[Laughs.]
Don Berliner, 77,
Job:
Aviation and science writer, Fund for UFO Research chairman
Ever
had a UFO experience?
Probably
not, which is not the answer you want. I saw something that seems to be related
to UFOs. There was a great flurry back in the late '40s and early '50s of green
fireballs. They looked like giant meteors, and I had a good sighting of one of
those. I long ago gave up looking. Though I still always get a window seat on an
airliner.
What
is it that most convinces you that UFOs exist?
Two
things. One, the consistency of sightings by expert witnesses -- professional
pilots, military and airline -- of oddly shaped vehicles seen in the broad
daylight. Vehicles whose shapes are not familiar and whose technical
performances are right off the scale. . . . The other is the federal
government's very suspicious behavior of putting outlandish explanations on UFO
reports, explanations and interpretations that don't reflect the body of the
report.
Why do
you think UFOs are visiting Earth?
Well, if
indeed they are and aren't explainable in some other way, I have absolutely no
idea. It's very risky to use human reasoning when you're dealing with something
you have defined as nonhuman.
How do
you deal with skeptics?
That's a
tricky word. The people who are convinced that UFOs don't exist or can't be of
any consequence call themselves skeptics, but they have a carved-in-stone
belief. I don't know what the right word is to describe them; we have some
unkind words. [Laughs.] Hey, maybe they're right; I don't know. But if you're
going to claim to be scientific in your outlook, you should be scientific in
your outlook.
Has
your involvement with the subject of UFOs hampered your relationships or career
plans?
Not that
I'm aware of. In the early days, when I was still in the Air Force, occasionally
I would try to get people interested and people would poke fun, but nothing
serious.
What
would it take to make acceptance of UFO phenomena more widespread?
I've got
a long list of things. Live video footage of a classic disc performing amazing
maneuvers. Physical evidence, say, from the
What about alien abductions? Do you believe in
those?
Oh, is
that a bag of worms. It is far beyond anything else in the UFO field for
bizarreness, but the reports we get from all over the world are highly
consistent. . . . It's something that deserves a lot more study. I'm certainly
not going to brush it off, but it is really far out.
Antonio Huneeus, 57,
Job: Freelance science reporter and editor
When
did you first get interested in UFOs?
There was
a very interesting case in
Ever
had a UFO experience?
Well, I
would only say that I have had a UFO sighting, not an experience or close
encounter. In the Chilean Andes, I did see some strange lights that were
zigzagging in the sky and moving in unexplained fashion. This was in 1988.
What
is it that most convinces you that UFOs exist?
Well,
there's just a lot of great evidence, once you filter all the noise and the wild
allegations. Unfortunately, the field is contaminated by a lot of
unsubstantiated rumors and sensationalism. Anybody that wants to get involved in
this has to realize this and filter it and get to the good cases.
Why do
you think UFOs are visiting Earth?
We have
no idea, to tell you the truth. That's why they are a mystery.
How do
you deal with skeptics?
I understand them, because I used to be skeptical. . . .
A certain degree of skepticism is healthy. And that applies to the believers'
side as well.
Has
your involvement with the subject of UFOs hampered your relationships or career
plans?
Perhaps
in the early years, I could sense that people would have kind of a funny
reaction. . . . But in the last 10 to 15 years, I understand that it's still not
treated seriously, but it has become part of the culture. People think it's an
exciting subject, and they want to know more. In some foreign countries, the
culture is much more disposed to accepting information about UFOs. In
What
would it take to make acceptance of UFO phenomena more widespread?
It would
help if we had a very dramatic, solid case with multiple witnesses. Some case
that could bring the phenomenon back to the front page.
Sue Swiatek, 49,
Job: Software
analyst and publishing specialist; Virginia
state director of the Mutual UFO Network
When
did you first get interested in UFOs?
I was 8
years old, and I read about the Betty and Barney Hill abduction case in Look
magazine. I took it very seriously; it had the ring of truth. I thought if they
can pick up one couple, they can pick up more. That's what led me to have a
lifelong interest.
Ever
had a UFO experience?
Well,
apparently. I was just driving along and saw something for five to seven
seconds, and I couldn't resolve it. It was a stubby fuselage, fatter than a
plane, and it wasn't tapered like a plane would be. It didn't have a tail or
wings. But you know as well as I do, if a plane's at a certain angle, you can't
tell. I'm very skeptical, so that's still in my gray basket. It was a big
object. . . . It was weird, I will say that.
What
is it that most convinces you that UFOs exist?
When I
get involved with local people in local cases and I see the fear in their eyes
and how serious they are about what they've seen. When you meet real people and
you know that they don't want publicity, they don't want their name in the
paper, it's very powerful when you meet them. . . . People who have close
encounters feel threatened. They think the UFOs might be coming back, they fear
the government and they feel their friends and family are going to ridicule
them.
Why do
you think UFOs are visiting Earth?
I believe
they are coming here to explore and glean some kind of resources from our
planet. Whether that's DNA material or something more prosaic, who can say?
Maybe it's just knowledge.
How do
you deal with skeptics?
I
personally don't mind skeptics. I don't get my feelings hurt. I am who I am.
Some people ask me questions about the fact that I'm a Christian. A guy once
said, "How can you believe in God and UFOs when there's no proof in either one?"
I think he thought my brain was going to explode.
Has
your involvement with the subject of UFOs hampered your relationships or career
plans?
So far,
no. This article may change that. [Laughs.] A lot of my friends are in the UFO
field. If people can't tolerate me believing this, then we're probably not going
to be that close anyway.
What
would it take to make acceptance of UFO phenomena more widespread?
We have
meetings about just this thing. The thing that would work the best we have no
control over, and that would be a major sighting or a wave of sightings that
involved a large geographic area. Or if there was a major disclosure by our
government, that would help.
Norm Gagnon, 47,
Job:
Graphic and architectural designer, UFO investigator
When
did you first get interested in UFOs?
In 1995,
I started investigating, researching, reading about it. I started to make a
little noise so that people could contact me if they have unusual sightings.
What
is it that most convinces you that UFOs exist?
I did
observe at least three sightings. I saw something, looked up and thought it was
very unusual. When I observed these I didn't think, "Hey, UFOs," I just thought,
"Wow, that's unusual." On one sighting, my wife and I saw two unusual
floating-type objects. I don't mean flying saucers or ships, I just mean
unidentified floating, flying objects.
There's
too many sightings out there. Something is going on. There is also a lot of
fraud out there, and I've seen a lot of pranks and movies on YouTube that are
fakes. One of my interests is trying to determine fakes by looking at photos and
visiting with people.
Why do
you think UFOs are visiting Earth?
There's
so much to say. I can't give you a simple sentence. I believe there are
formidable forces outside our physical realm of time-space and these
extra-dimensional beings have been hovering our skies and even visiting us since
the beginning of human history. One of my objectives as a ufologist is to not
only document these sightings but, most important, to help the folks that may
have been affected be these encounters.
How do
you deal with skeptics?
Well,
myself, I'm a skeptic sitting almost on the fence. I do believe what people say
they see are manifestations and aerial phenomena. However, I cannot point the
finger and say that these are absolutely from another universe. I say these are
manifestations that could have been created on Earth. I also believe that our
government has vehicles that they test which are top secret which sometimes fly
away from where they are supposed to be. They are futuristic, man-made vehicles
that we don't know about. But as to aliens, I do not believe, personally, that
there is any alien visitation.
Has
your involvement with the subject of UFOs hampered your relationships or career
plans?
Um, not
really. As to my work, my regular day job, I really don't talk about it. Most
people don't talk about it. My involvement is usually outside work and with
groups like MUFON. My passion is that I love investigating, just getting down to
the ground level and looking for evidence that can be collected.
My wife
is aware of what I'm doing, and she's not too crazy about what I do. But I'm not
going to stay in this [field] for the rest of my life. I'm collecting reports or
photographs for a book I'd like to write.
Ben Moss, 52,
Job:
Information technology consultant
How
old were you when you first started exploring ufology?
I was a
kid. Probably 7 or 8. Walter Cronkite did a UFO show, and I was fascinated from
that point forth. The media was a lot more open than it is now.
Ever
had a UFO experience?
There's
one thing I saw in college that looked like a cruise missile prototype. I heard
a whistle and then rockets fired on its side, and it started climbing away at
rapid speed. This was in the mountains of
What
is it that most convinces you that UFOs exist?
Well, I
think
Why do
you think UFOs are visiting Earth?
Well, if
you know anything about astronomy, you know we have a fairly young sun. The more
we look, the more we see that there are systems out there that are like ours but
much older. Anything that's of a high technology, say 500 years advanced from
what we have, will look like magic to us. Perhaps like things that our minds
can't process.
It makes
sense that we're being monitored by other beings. The theory is that man is a
very aggressive race and that they want to put restraints on us or to prevent us
from attacking them. We're a warlike race, and if you're studying it, you need
to figure out how to control it.
How do
you deal with skeptics?
I'll just
logically try to argue the point. A reporter or someone in public office is not
going to talk about UFOs because of the ridicule, and that's tough to overcome.
If someone firmly believes that none of this is true, then it's never going to
be true to them.
Has
your involvement with the subject of UFOs hampered your relationships or career
plans?
I pretty
much do my own thing. But, no, I don't blurt it out a lot. I don't mind talking
to friends about it. I can argue in a logical way and point to evidence.